Parenting: It Doesn’t Come in a Can

by admin on June 9, 2010

It doesn’t come in a can” was a favorite saying of a friend of mine’s father. He was a golf pro, and when he said this he was referring to golf, most of the time. I have been thinking about this saying in reference to parenting a lot recently.

I think a lot of people parent out of instinct. They figure they will go with what their gut tells them to do. I take issue with this parenting style.

Back to the golf thing for a second. When I set up to hit a golf ball off the tee on a par 5 my instincts tell me to swing as hard as I possibly can and hit the living sh– out of the ball. If you know anything about golf, then you probably know how well that will turn out – slice, hook, or most likely whiff the ball altogether. To drive a ball down the middle of the fairway takes a smooth swing, a ton of practice, and most importantly a calm state of mind.

Back to parenting. When kids don’t listen our instincts tell us to speak louder, and louder, and louder. Here is the flaw with our instincts. When you yell at your kids you are disrupting healthy brain development. ~brain geek alert~ Throughout children’s development their brains undergo massive pruning – as much as 50% of the brain’s 200 billion neurons. Your yelling impacts which brain structures receive the bulk of that pruning.

When we yell at our children we activate structures in the limbic system that regulate “fight or flight” reactions. Repeated activation to these areas tells the brain that their environment is not safe, thus the interconnecting neurons in these areas must remain intact. Because pruning has to happen, neurons will be pruned from structures like the prefrontal cortex where higher cognitive functions (attention, planning, decision-making, critical thinking) tend to be regulated. In essence, when you follow your instinct and resign to yelling at your kids you are impairing their intellectual and emotional development. ~end brain geek part~ Figure out another way.

Back to golf. No amount of instinct, no matter how talented you may be, is going to win you a golf tournament. It takes practice, a lot of practice. It takes lessons from someone who knows how to play golf. And more than anything, it takes a calm state of mind. And parenting… you get the idea – it doesn’t come in a can.

Sadly, most people I know will spend more time and money on learning to play golf than learning to be a good parent. If you know someone like that (perhaps your husband or your wife) please encourage them to read a good parenting book, learn from a good parent, practice what will be the most important job they will ever have and remind them, it doesn’t come in a can.

Some of my favorite parenting books include: Parenting from the Inside Out by Daniel Siegel and Mary Hartzell, Parenting Preschoolers with a Purpose by Jolene Roehlkepartain, The Blessing of a Skinned Knee by Wendy Mogel, and Nurture Shock by Po Bronson. Please use the comment space below to share comments as well as your favorite parenting resources!

This blog is dedicated to T-Man. A great golfer and a fantastic parent!


  • Laurabarr
    In my work as a Parenting Coach I like to use the word "Intentional" as opposed to using "instinct." When we are intentional we are clear and deliberate in our parenting style. The problem is that so many books tell us about 100 different ways to do this and they give great examples of how to do it, we try it and when it doesn't work we can't always figure out the next step alone. I like to think of parenting as something I practice just like cooking or yoga. It takes time for to try a new technique and I need a friend, my mom or my own coach to help guide me! Thanks for the great article. Laura Barr www.e-merging.org
  • Suestern
    i love the book parenting from the inside out and will joyfully look at your other suggestions. I enjoyed your posting and agree. As a mental health professional it is also humbling to realize that parents 'instincts' are more usually some combination of their own experience mixed with their reaction to that experience be it imitative or reactive. This is often equated with an instinct but other than fight and flight, it usually isn't that at all. maybe that is the point. there may be no such thing as a parenting instinct at all.
  • martibabb
    Thank you Kristen! Great article. My Dad would be so touched that you dedicated this to him. But, most of all he would be honored that you thought of him as a Fantastic parent! He was the BEST!
    Good luck to you!
    Marti









  • Kristen
    Marti,
    Thanks for reading and I'm so glad you liked it! I'm so glad I had the opportunity to know him!
    Kristen
blog comments powered by Disqus

Previous post:

Next post:

Real Time Web Analytics